BUILDING
A BETTER BIKE LANE
Bike-friendly
cities in Europe are launching a
new attack on car culture. Can the U.S. catch up?
By NANCY
KEATES -
May 4, 2007; Page W1 - The
Wall Street Journal
COPENHAGEN -- No one wears bike helmets
here. They're afraid they'll mess up
their hair. "I
have a big head and I would look silly," Mayor
Klaus Bondam says.
People
bike while pregnant, carrying two cups of
coffee, smoking, eating bananas.
At the
airport, there are parking spaces for bikes.
In the emergency room at Frederiksberg
Hospital on weekends, half the biking
accidents are
from people riding drunk. Doctors say the
drunk riders tend to run into poles.
Flat, compact and temperate, the Netherlands
and Denmark have long been havens for bikers.
In Amsterdam, 40% of commuters get to work
by bike. In Copenhagen, more than a third
of workers pedal to their offices. But
as concern
about global warming intensifies -- the
European Union is already under emissions
caps and
tougher restrictions are expected -- the
two cities
are leading a fresh assault on car culture.
A major thrust is a host of aggressive
new measures designed to shift bike commuting
into higher gear, including increased prison
time
for bike thieves and the construction of
new parking facilities that can hold up
to
10,000
bikes.
The rest of Europe is paying close attention.
Officials from London, Munich and Zurich
(plus a handful from the U.S.) have
visited Amsterdam's
transportation department for advice
on developing bicycle-friendly infrastructure
and policies.
Norway aims to raise bicycle traffic
to
at least 8% of all travel by 2015 --
double its current level -- while Sweden
hopes
to
move
from 12% to 16% by 2010. This summer,
Paris will put thousands of low-cost
rental bikes
throughout the city to cut traffic,
reduce pollution and improve parking.
The
city of Copenhagen plans to double its spending
on biking infrastructure
over the
next three years, and Denmark is
about to unveil a plan to increase
spending
on bike
lanes on
2,000 kilometers, or 1,240 miles,
of roads. Amsterdam is undertaking
an
ambitious capital-improvement
program that includes building a
10,000-bike parking garage at the main
train station
-- construction is expected to start
by the end
of next year. The city is also trying
to boost public transportation usage,
and
plans to soon
enforce stricter car-parking fines
and increase parking fees to discourage
people
from driving.
Worried that immigrants might push
car use up, both cities have started
training
programs
to teach non-natives how to ride
bikes and are stepping up bike
training of
children in schools. There are
bike-only bridges
under
consideration and efforts to make
intersections more rider-friendly
by putting in special
mirrors.
The policy goal is to have bicycle
trips replace many short car
trips, which account
for 6%
of total emissions from cars,
according to a document adopted last
month
by the European
Economic and Social Committee,
an organization of transportation
ministers
from EU
member countries. Another report
published this
year by the Dutch Cyclists' Association
found that
if all trips shorter than 7.5
kilometers in the Netherlands currently
made
by car were
by bicycle, the country would
reduce its carbon-dioxide emissions
by
2.4 million
tons. That's about
one-eighth of the amount of emissions
it would need to reduce to meet
the Kyoto
Protocol.
Officials
from some American cities have made pilgrimages
to Amsterdam.
But in
the U.S.,
bike commuters face more challenges,
including strong opposition
from
some small businesses,
car owners and parking-garage
owners to any proposals to
remove parking,
shrink driving
lanes or reduce speed limits.
Some argue that limiting car
usage would
hurt business. "We
haven't made the tough decisions yet," says
Sam Adams, city commissioner
of Portland, Ore., who visited
Amsterdam in 2005.
There has been
some movement. Last month,
New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg
announced a proposal
to add a congestion
charge on cars and increase
the number of bicycle paths
in the city. It would
also require commercial
buildings to have indoor parking
facilities for bikes.
Even in Amsterdam, not everyone
is pro-biking. Higher-end shops
have
already moved out
of the city center because of
measures to decrease
car traffic, says Geert-Pieter
Wagenmakers, an adviser to Amsterdam's
Chamber
of Commerce, and now shops in
the outer
ring of the
city are vulnerable. Bikes parked
all over the
sidewalk are bad for business,
he adds.
Still, the new measures in Amsterdam
and Copenhagen add to an infrastructure
that
has already made
biking an integral part of life.
People haul groceries in saddle
bags or on
handlebars and tote their children
in multiple bike
seats.
Companies have indoor bike parking,
changing rooms and on-site bikes
for employees to
take to meetings. Subways have
bike cars and ramps
next to the stairs.
Riding
a bike for some has more cachet than driving
a Porsche.
Dutch Prime
Minister Jan
Peter Balkenende sometimes
rides to work, as do
lawyers,
CEOs
(Lars Rebien
Sorensen,
chief
executive of Danish pharmaceutical
giant Novo Nordisk, is
famous
for his on-bike
persona) and members
of parliament, often with
empty
children's seats in back.
Dutch Prince Maurits
van Oranje is
often seen
riding around town. "It's
a good way to keep in touch with people on
the streets," says
Tjeerd Herrema, deputy
mayor of
Amsterdam. Mr. Herrema's
car and driver
still make the trip sometimes
-- to chauffeur his bag
when he has too much
work to
carry.
Jolanda Engelhamp let her husband
keep her car when they
split up a few years
ago because
it was becoming too
expensive to park. Now the 47-year-old
takes
her second-grade
son
to school on the back
of her
bike. (It's a half-hour
ride from home.)
Outside the
school
in Amsterdam, harried
moms drop off children, checking backpacks
and
coats; men in suits
pull up, with children's
seats
in back, steering while
talking on their
cellphones.
It's a
typical drop-off scene,
only without cars.
For Khilma van der
Klugt, a 38-year-old
bookkeeper,
biking
is more about
health and convenience
than concern for
the environment. Her two
older children
ride their own bikes
on
the 25-minute
commute to school
while she ferries the four-year-old
twins in a
big box attached
to the front
of her bike. Biking
gives her children
exercise
and fresh
air in the morning,
which helps
them
concentrate, she
says. "It gets all their
energy out." She
owns a car, but she only
uses
it when the weather is
really bad or she's
feeling especially lazy.
Caroline Vonk, a
38-year-old government
official,
leaves home by
bike at 8 a.m. and drops
off
her two children
at a day-care
center. By 8:15,
she's on her way
to work,
stopping to drop
clothes at the
dry cleaner or to buy
some rolls
for lunch. On the
way home,
she makes
a quick
stop at a shop,
picks up the children and
is home
by 5:55. "It is a pleasant way to
clear my head," she
says.
Teaching Newcomers
The programs for
non-natives
target those who view
biking as a lower
form of transportation
than cars. "If they don't start cycling
it will hurt," says
Marjolein de
Lange, who
heads Amsterdam's
pro-bicycle
union Fietsersbond
and has worked
with local
councils to
set up classes
for immigrant
women.
On a recent
Sunday afternoon,
23
women --
many in head-scarves
--
gathered
at a recreational
center north
of
Amsterdam
to
follow seven
Fietsersbond
volunteers
to learn
to navigate
through
traffic.
The three-hour
event
cost €3
(about $4)
and included
practice weaving
in and out
of
orange cones
and over blocks
of wood. It
ended
with
all of the
women gathering
in a park for
cake and lemonade.
Though she
faltered
at times,
Rosie
Soemer,
a 36-year-old
mother
of two who came
to the
Netherlands from
Suriname,
was sold. "It
is so much easier to go everywhere by bike," she
says. Learning to ride was her husband's idea:
He bought her a bicycle for her birthday a
few months earlier and has been spending his
lunch hour teaching her in a park. "It
helps me if she can get around better," says
her husband, Sam Soemer. "And
it's safer
than a car."
Amsterdam
and Copenhagen
are
generally
safer
for bikers
than
the U.S.
because
high
car taxes and
gasoline
prices
tend
to keep
sport-utility
vehicles
off the
road.
In Denmark,
the
tax for
buying
a new
car is
as high
as 180%.
Drivers
must
be over
18 to
get a license,
and
the tests
are so
hard
that most people
fail
the first
few times.
Both
cities have worked
to train
truck
drivers to look
out for
bikers
when
they
turn right at
intersections,
and changed
mirrors
on vehicles
and at
traffic
corners
so they're
positioned
for viewing
cyclists.
As bike
lanes
become
more
crowded,
new
measures
have
been
added
to
address bike
safety.
A
recent
survey
found
that
people
in
Denmark
felt
less
safe
biking,
though
the
risk of getting
killed
in
a bike
accident
there
has
fallen
by
almost
half.
(The
number
of
bicyclists
killed
fell
to
31 in 2006
from
53
in
2004,
and
the number
seriously
injured
dropped
to
567
from
726
in that
period.)
According
to
one emergency
room's
statistics,
the
primary
reason
for
accidents is people
being
hit
by car doors
opening;
second
is
cars
making
right-hand
turns
and
hitting bikers
at
intersections; third
is
bike-on-bike
crashes.
Bike-riding
police
officers
now
routinely fine
cyclists
in
Amsterdam
who
don't
have
lights
at
night.
Parking
for
10,000
Amsterdam
is
also
working
to
improve
the
lack
of
parking.
The
city
built
five
bike-parking
garages
over
the
past
five
years
and
plans
a
new
one
every
year,
including
one
with
10,000
spaces
at
the
central
railroad
station.
(While
there's
room
for
2,000
bikes
now,
there
are
often
close
to
4,000
bikes
there.)
But
even
garages
aren't
enough.
Bikers
usually
want
to
park
right
outside
wherever
they're
going
--
they
don't
like
parking
and
walking.
Combating
theft is
an important
plank in
developing a
bike-friendly culture.
In 2003,
the city
created the
Amsterdam Bicycle
Recovery Center,
a large
warehouse where
illegally parked
bikes are
taken. (Its
acronym in
Dutch is
AFAC.) Every
bike that
goes through
AFAC is
first checked
against a
list of
stolen bikes.
After three
months, unclaimed
models are
registered, engraved
with a
serial number
and sold
to a
second-hand shop.
At any
one time,
the center
has about
6,000 bikes
neatly arranged
by day
of confiscation,
out of
an estimated
total of
600,000 bikes
in the
city.
How
AFAC will
encourage bike
riding in
Amsterdam is
a somewhat
perverse logic,
because it
means some
200 bikes
are confiscated
by city
officials a
day compared
to a
handful before
it existed.
The thinking
is that
the more
bikes that
are confiscated,
the more
bikes can
be registered
and the
better the
government can
trace stolen
bikes. The
less nervous
people are
that their
bikes will
be stolen,
the more
likely they
are to
ride. "Is your bike gone? Check
AFAC first," is
the center's slogan.
Remco
Keyzer did
just that
on a
recent Monday
morning. The
music teacher
had parked
his bike
outside the
central station
before heading
to a
class and
returned to
find it
gone. "I
can be mad, but that really wouldn't help me," he
says. Sometimes people
ride
away without paying
the required fee. Bruno
Brand, who helps people
find their bikes at AFAC,
says people get mad,
but he explains it is
the local
police, not
him, who confiscated the
bike.
Within
the past
four years,
the city
increased the
fine for
buying or
selling a
bike in
the street.
Punishment for
stealing a
bike is
now up
to three
months in
jail.
Danish
and Dutch
officials say
their countries
might have
been more
congested if
protests in
the 1970s
and 1980s
had not
sparked the
impetus for
building bicycle-lane
networks. The
arguments for
more biking
were mostly
about health
and congestion
-- only
in the
past year
has the
environment started
to be
a factor.
Proponents of
better infrastructure
point to
China as
an example:
In Beijing,
where the
economy has
boomed, 30.3%
of people
commuted to
work on
bikes in
2005, down
8.2% from
2000, according
to a
survey by
the Beijing
Transportation Development
Research
Center and
Beijing Municipal
Committee of
Communication.
Now,
the Dansk
Cyklist Forbund,
the Danish
Cyclist's Federation,
says that
to make
progress it
can't be
too confrontational
and must
recognize that
many bikers
also have
cars. "Our
goal is the right means of transportation for
the right trips," says
director Jens Loft
Rasmussen.
In
comparison, the
rules of
the American
road can
take some
adjustment, as
Cheryl AndristPlourde
has found
when she
visits her
parents in
Columbus, Ohio.
Last summer,
the Amsterdam
resident enrolled
her 8-year-old
daughter in
a camp
close to
her parents'
house. The
plan was
for her
daughter, who
biked to
school every
day back
home, to
walk to
camp. But
her daughter
whined about
the 10-minute
walk --
all the
other kids
drove, she
said --
and the
streets were
too busy
for her
to bike.
By the
third day,
Ms. AndristPlourde
was driving
her daughter
to the
camp.
Bike-Friendly
Cities in
the U.S.
A
number of
towns have
recently focused
on making
roads more
accessible to
bicycles. Here
are some
of the
top spots
chosen by
the Bicycle
Friendly Community
Campaign from
the League
of American
Bicyclists, an
advocacy group
based in
Washington, D.C.
| CITY |
%
OF ARTERIAL ROADS WITH BIKE LANES |
%
OF COMMUTERS WHO BIKE |
COMMENTS |
| Boulder,
Colo. |
97% |
21% |
Boulder
has spent an average 15% of its transportation
budget on building and maintaining bicycle
traffic over the past five years. The
goal is to create a system that's "equitable
for all users," with no hierarchy
among pedestrians, cars and bikes, says
Marni Ratzel, who runs the city's program. |
| Chicago |
11% |
1-2% |
Mayor
Richard Michael Daley bikes to work,
setting the example for this city, which released
an ambitious new bike plan last year.
The goal: making all of Chicago's streets
safe and convenient for cycling. |
| Davis,
Calif. |
95% |
17% |
Mostly flat and temperate, this town's logo is a bicycle; it has more bikes than
cars and is the only place to earn platinum status on Bicycle Friendly Community's
list of top cities. The city is about to build a $1.7 million bike-only tunnel
under a major road. |
| Madison,
Wisc. |
About
37% |
3.2% |
There
are 32 miles of bike lanes, 35 miles
of bike paths and more than 100 miles
of signed bike routes. On University
Avenue, the major street in the downtown and
University of Wisconsin campus area, there
can be over 10,000 bicyclists a day --
plus 30,000 cars. |
| Palo
Alto, Calif. |
13% |
5.7% |
Along
with the bike lanes on roads, the city
also has nine miles of bike paths. In
2004 it spent about $5 million on a rail
line under-crossing and $1.5 million
on a 0.8-mile bike path. |
| Portland,
Ore. |
28% |
5.4% |
Though
there are lots of hills and rain, this
city has 163 miles of bike lanes. All
but two bridges accommodate bicyclists.
There's still a long way to go: The city
still has 38 miles of bike lanes left
in order to achieve its master plan.
But in some neighborhoods bike commuters
are as high as 9%. |
| San
Francisco |
About
4% |
2.1% |
In
November 2003, San Francisco voters approved
a half-cent sales tax measure, estimated
to total $2.6 billion over 30 years.
Of that, $56 million (a little more than 2%)
will go to bike-related projects. |
|